Moments in Trade #26|An inquiry too good to be true

Moments in Trade #26|An inquiry too good to be true
This series uses Dingli, a Patisco demo account. Every system screen and all the data shown here came from real operations in the system, including the exchanges between buyers and suppliers; they are not mock-ups. The people and dialogue are dramatized, and the illustrations are for illustration only. Screens are shown in the system's Chinese interface; Patisco is also available in English and other languages.

In the story: the Tuesday Bram wrote back, 10:20 a.m.

Twice as much

The email was in English, and beautifully written.

A "major regional distributor" in Dubai said they were looking for a new chain and cassette supplier. A-Zhe ran the numbers on their annual volume: twice Northwind's. Payment terms: they could pay 30% upfront.

Just one request: please send the full price list first, plus spec files for every product, so their engineering department could evaluate.

"Chairman!" A-Zhe nearly jumped out of his chair. "If this comes through, it makes up for Northwind!"

Chairman Lin leaned out of his office and said nothing.

Xiao-Yu's hunch

Xiao-Yu read the email from top to bottom.

"A-Zhe, this email... it reads a little too smoothly."

"They just write good English."

"No, it's that every sentence hits exactly what we want to hear." Xiao-Yu scrolled on his phone. "And their company website was only registered last month."

A-Zhe went quiet.

Xiao-Yu went on: "Also, the same day, they clicked [Becoming a Member] on our public page."

How it used to go

What would A-Zhe have done with an email like this in the old days?

He'd have excitedly tidied up the price list in Excel, with distributor prices, shop prices and every tier discount, attached spec PDFs for every product, and sent the whole thing that same day.

And then the other side would vanish.

Three months later, a competitor would show up at Velostrada with a very familiar-looking spreadsheet, every cell just a little cheaper than Dingli. Once a price list goes out, you can't get it back.

How it goes in Patisco

The application comes in and waits

That [Becoming a Member] application shows up on Dingli's side as a buyer with the status "Uninvited": company name, country, contact person, email, all filled in by the applicant.

Buyer Management: an application with the status Uninvited, from Desert Crest Cycle Distribution FZE (UAE, Dubai), no invitation sent
An application the other side filled in themselves: while it sits, nothing happens. Whether to let it through is your call.

Hsiu-Chin walked over and took a look.

"Let it sit," she said. "Until we've seen money and checked the company out, it doesn't go through."

While the application sits, nothing happens. Unless Dingli sends an invitation, the other side never gets connected and can't see the catalogs and prices Dingli shares with its buyers.

Products yes, distributor prices no

So what can they see right now?

They came in through a public page. On "Dingli Parts|USA," visitors can see product photos, specs and the channel price. Distributor prices and shop prices, they can't.

The "Dingli Parts|USA" page as a visitor sees it: the product list shows only the channel price
Strangers can see the products and the channel price; distributor prices require approval first.

Which price each visitor sees is decided by the trading terms the public page uses, and Dingli set that up in advance. A stranger can find out what Dingli sells. To see distributor prices, they have to get approved first.

People make the call

A-Zhe wrote back, very politely: "Thank you for your interest. Please find our product range here [link]. To discuss distributor pricing, could we arrange a video call first?"

They replied the next day: the boss was traveling, so could Dingli please just send the price list.

A-Zhe tried once more to set up a call. No reply.

That application is still sitting in [Buyer Management] today, status "Uninvited."

"So the system knew it was fake?" Xiao-Yu asked.

"No," said A-Zhe. "You're the one who thought it was off. What the system does is make sure the price list doesn't go out before we've made up our minds."

Before vs. With Patisco

BeforeWith Patisco
A stranger asks for the price listSent the same day in the excitementThe public page shows only the one price you set in advance
Wanting to become a buyerOne email and quoting beginsThey apply via [Becoming a Member]; the seller reviews before sending an invitation
Deciding whether they're realFind out after it's sentPeople decide; until then, distributor prices don't go out
Price list leaksCan't get it backIt was never sent
A word for the boss: The system won't tell you who's a scammer. What it does is let you hold on to your cards until you've made up your mind.

The real-world backdrop: Patisco's founder once ran into a "perfect stranger" on LinkedIn, firsthand. Further reading (in Chinese): "I just ran into an 'AI pig-butchering' scam on LinkedIn"

Further reading

Next episodeMoments in Trade #27|'Are you really made in Taiwan?'That same week, Jonas did something rare: he emailed first.Not to haggle, and not to chase a shipment. He asked a question he'd never once asked in all their years of working together.Read the next episode →
Share:
Facing this problem yourself?
Book 20 minutes and walk through it with your own data. Nothing to prepare.
See it on real screens →